Induced pluripotent stem-cell-derived corneal epithelium for transplant surgery: a single-arm, open-label, first-in-human interventional study in Japan
The loss of corneal epithelial stem cells from the limbus at the edge of the cornea has severe consequences for vision, with the pathological manifestations of a limbal stem-cell deficiency (LSCD) difficult to treat. Here, to the best of our knowledge, we report the world's first use of corneal epithelial cell sheets derived from human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) to treat LSCD.
Methods
This non-randomised, single-arm, clinical study involved four eyes of four patients with LSCD at the Department of Ophthalmology, Osaka University Hospital. They comprised a woman aged 44 years with idiopathic LSCD (patient 1), a man aged 66 years with ocular mucous membrane pemphigoid (patient 2), a man aged 72 years with idiopathic LSCD (patient 3), and a woman aged 39 years with toxic epidermal necrosis (patient 4). Allogeneic human iPSC-derived corneal epithelial cell sheets (iCEPSs) were transplanted onto affected eyes. This was done sequentially in two sets of HLA-mismatched surgeries, with patients 1 and 2 receiving low-dose cyclosporin and patients 3 and 4 not. The primary outcome measure was safety, ascertained by adverse events. These were monitored continuously throughout the 52-week follow-up period, and during an additional 1-year safety monitoring period. Secondary outcomes, reflective of efficacy, were also recorded. This study is registered with UMIN, UMIN000036539 and is complete.
Findings
Patients were enrolled between June 17, 2019 and Nov 16, 2020. We had 26 adverse events during the 52-week follow-up period (consisting of 18 mild and one moderate event in treated eyes, and seven mild non-ocular events), with nine recorded in the additional 1-year safety monitoring period. No serious adverse events, such as tumourigenesis or clinical rejection, occurred during the whole 2-year observational period. At 52 weeks, secondary measures of efficacy showed that the disease stage had improved, corrected distance visual acuity was enhanced, and corneal opacification had diminished in all treated eyes. Corneal epithelial defects, subjective symptoms, quality-of-life questionnaire scores and corneal neovascularisation mostly improved or were unchanged. Overall, the beneficial efficacy outcomes achieved for patients 1 and 2 were better than those achieved for patients 3 and 4.
Interpretation
iCEPS transplantation for LSCD was found to be safe throughout the study period. A larger clinical trial is planned to further investigate the efficacy of the procedure.
Funding
The Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development, the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science, and Technology—Japan, and the UK Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council.
Introduction
The cornea of the eye is overlaid by a stratified epithelium that is essential for vision. At the limbus—an anatomical zone situated at the edge of the cornea where it adjoins the sclera (the white of the eye)—the corneal epithelium contains a reservoir of stem cells, which are located basally.1 These cells proliferate to provide a continuous supply of epithelial cells to the central cornea, maintaining its healthy state. Corneal limbal epithelial stem cells are highly proliferative, express p63 transcription factor, and exhibit holoclone-forming capabilities.2 In their absence, or when insufficient numbers are present, patients suffer from a condition known as a limbal stem-cell deficiency (LSCD).3 A unilateral LSCD is often associated with acquired non-immune-mediated aetiologies such as trauma to the eye caused by thermal or chemical burns. Bilateral LSCDs can be caused by acquired primary immune-mediated aetiologies (for example, Stevens-Johnson syndrome or ocular mucous membrane pemphigoid) or idiopathic or hereditary disease such as congenital aniridia.3 Whatever its origin, an LSCD typically leads to the enveloping of the corneal surface by fibrotic conjunctival tissue and a consequent loss of vision.
The management of an LSCD necessitates the optimisation of the ocular surface and subsequent surgical removal of conjunctival scar tissue from the corneal surface, followed by a graft of functional corneal epithelial tissue.4 The choice of graft material depends on the type of disease. For patients with a unilateral LSCD, autologous transplant procedures should initially be considered because they tend to engender better long-term graft survival. Such surgeries include keratolimbal autografts,5 autologous cultivated limbal epithelial cell transplantation,6–8 and autologous simple limbal transplantation,9 in which tissue biopsies are obtained from the patient's unaffected eye. If a patient suffers from a bilateral LSCD, however, no autologous ocular tissue is available, so candidate procedures include cadaveric limbal stem-cell transplantation,10 allogeneic cultivated limbal epithelial cell transplantation (including in situations in which the biopsy can be obtained from a living related donor),11 allogeneic cultivated limbal epithelial cell transplantation,12 and autologous cultivated oral mucosal epithelial cell sheet transplantation.13,14 Despite the value of these treatments, the autologous and allogeneic approaches both come with drawbacks. These include the requirement for a biopsy of healthy limbus or oral mucosal epithelial tissue for autologous procedures, with the variability of autologous cell sources and individual fabrication regimes contributing to a sometimes uncertain outcome.15 In addition, postoperative neovascularisation following cultivated oral mucosal epithelial cell sheet transplantation is inevitable, variable in its severity, and very difficult to manage.13,14 Allogeneic therapies are accompanied by problems that include the risk of immunological rejction.10
Research in context
Evidence before this study
We assessed the scientific literature for reports of patients with a limbal stem cell deficiency (LSCD) in which induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) were used. A search of PubMed from the database's inception to April 4, 2024 was done with the terms “limbal stem cell deficiency” AND “induced pluripotent stem cells” with no language restriction. This identified 22 articles, the majority of which were review articles. No clinical studies where iPSC-related cells were applied to patients with an LSCD were found. The choice of surgery for LSCD depends on whether or not one or both eyes are affected. For patients with unilateral LSCD, autologous transplant procedures should be considered as the first surgical option because they offer better long-term graft survival potential and avoid the risks related to systemic immunosuppression that is required following allogeneic transplant surgery.
Added value of this study
To our knowledge, this is the first use of iPSC-derived corneal epithelial cells in transplant surgery. The procedure, grafting iPSC-derived corneal epithelial cell sheets (iCEPS) onto the ocular surface after the removal of fibrotic tissue that envelops the ocular surface, was successful and well-tolerated 2 years postoperatively in all four operated eyes. We found no safety issues (eg, clinical immunological rejection or tumour formation) throughout the whole 2-year observational period in any of the patients. At the end of the initial 52-week follow-up period, all four eyes also showed positive results clinically, with an improvement in the clinical stage of the disease, better visual acuity, and diminished corneal opacification. The outcomes were achieved without HLA matching or the use of immunosuppressive agents, apart from corticosteroids. This can probably be explained by a relatively low expression of HLA class I and II, and an absence of immunocompetent cells, such as Langerhans cell, from iCEPS.
Implications of all the available evidence
We describe a series of first-in-human surgeries that use human iPSC-derived epithelial cell sheets to repair the corneas of patients with visual impairment because of an LSCD.
Here, we report a novel regenerative therapy for an LSCD that uses human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs; figure 1A). The approach is based on our development of a self-formed, ectodermal, autonomous, multizone (SEAM) cultivation protocol that effectively produces precursor cells of ocular tissues from human iPSCs.16 This groundbreaking method partly mimics whole-eye development, and from SEAMs we have successfully fabricated functional ocular tissues including conjunctiva and lacrimal gland.17,18 The SEAM technology also facilitates the generation of human iPSC-derived corneal epithelial cell sheets (iCEPSs), which were able to reconstruct the cornea in an experimentally induced animal corneal injury model.16
I thought I had it all until the note on my door shattered my perfect world: "You stole my life." At first, I dismissed it. But when a mysterious package arrived, the past I never knew came rushing back.