The first, a formal demand to dismiss all charges against Naomi Green, supported by Derek Taylor's unedited footage and Earl Johnson's security recordings. The second, the one that made Richard Davises phone ring at 6:00 a.m. Was a counter suit, not just against Courtney Davis, against Westfield University itself. Systemic negligence, failure to protect a student from documented racial harassment, deliberate suppression of evidence. The war had just begun. The hearing was held on a Wednesday morning, room 401, Whitmore Administrative Building.
Long Oak Table, 12 chairs on one side, the board of trustees, two chairs on the other for the accused. Naomi arrived at 8:00 a.m. With Aunt Lorraine and Monica Williams. She wore a plain white blouse and black pants. No jewelry, no expression. She sat down and folded her hands on the table.
Across the aisle, Courtney Davis sat between two attorneys in tailored suits. Richard Davis was behind them. Board member or not, he was here as a father today. Brett Wilson sat in the back row, arms crossed, jaw tight. The Davis side looked like a fortress.
Money, lawyers, confidence. Naomi's side looked like three women at a kitchen table. But Monica Williams had something the Davis lawyers didn't. She had the truth, and she had it on video. The board chair, Dr. Patricia Coleman, 71, former federal judge, called the hearing to order.
She was the one person on that board who owed the Davis family nothing. Appointed by the state governor, not the donor list. This hearing will address two matters. Coleman said the disciplinary case against Miss Green and the counter suit filed against the university. We will hear evidence, we will hear testimony, and we will vote.
Williams stood first. I'd like to begin with a timeline, she said. Not of one incident, of an entire semester. She connected a laptop to the room's projector. The screen lit up.
First clip. Earl Johnson's footage dated 8 weeks ago. A dorm hallway camera, the one the university claimed had malfunctioned. It worked perfectly. On screen.
Brett Wilson shoulder-checking Naomi so hard her books scattered across the floor. He kept walking. She picked them up alone. No staff member in sight. Second clip. 5 weeks ago.
Courtney and two friends blocking the cafeteria entrance as Naomi tried to walk in. Courtney mouthing something. No audio, but the body language was unmistakable. Naomi turning around, walking away, eating nothing that day. Third clip. 3 weeks ago.
Naomi's dorm door. 2:00 a.m. A hand later identified as belonging to one of Courtney's sorority sisters taping a piece of paper to the door. Block letters. Go home. The room was quiet. Williams pulled up the next document.
A printed complaint, Naomi's handwriting, submitted to Dean Moore's office, datestamped, signed at the front desk. This complaint was received by the dean's office, Williams said, acknowledged, stamped, filed, and then nothing. No investigation, no follow-up, no contact with Miss Green. She pulled up a second complaint. Same result.