Every Woman Wanted the Lonely Cowboy — Until One Fearless Woman Spoke the Truth

Chapter 4

Reader Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That's hard. Yes. And after after I discovered he'd borrowed money to pay his medical bills, money we didn't have, money that came due the week after his funeral. Sarah's voice didn't waver. She'd told this story too many times for it to hurt the way it once had.

The creditors took everything. The house, the furniture, the silver, the linens, everything except the clothes on our backs and my mother's wedding ring. You still have the ring. I sold it. The words still tasted bitter.

Last week in Helena to buy stage tickets to Silver Creek. He was quiet for a moment. That must have been difficult. It was metal and stone. My children needed food.

Is that what you tell yourself? Sarah met his eyes. It's what's true. Sentiment doesn't keep bodies warm, Mr. Monroe.

It doesn't fill empty stomachs. I learned that the hard way. Most people don't survive that kind of learning. Most people have other options. Another silence.

The snow continued to fall. Why here? Caleb asked. Why Montana? Why Silver Creek?

Because it was far. Because no one knew me. Because I couldn't stay where I was and I didn't know where else to go. Sarah pulled her coat tighter. I've spent two years running Mr.

Monroe, running from debt collectors and bad memories and the constant reminder of everything I lost. I'm tired of running. So, you want to stop here? I want to stop. Whether it's here or somewhere else depends on the next hour.

He turned away, looking out at the frozen landscape, the mountains in the distance, the endless white. You asked me a question earlier, he said about wanting a wife versus wanting another winter alone. I remember it wasn't a fair question. Most questions aren't. He almost smiled.

Almost. The truth is I don't want either. I don't want a wife who leave when something better comes along. And I don't want another winter of talking to myself because there's no one else. He turned back to face her.

I've built something here, Mrs. Jenkins. Something that works, something I control. And I don't trust anything I can't control, including people, especially people. His voice hardened.

I trusted a woman once. Loved her even. I was building that house for us, planning a future, working towards something. And she walked away without a word, just gone. Like nothing I'd done mattered.

Like I didn't matter. Margaret. His eyes flashed. Mrs. Thornton really does talk too much.

She talks because she cares. The people in this town care about you whether you want them to or not. Sarah took a step closer. But I'm not Margaret. I'm not here because you're handsome or because you own land or because I think I can change you.

I'm here because I'm desperate and you're available and I'm hoping we can help each other survive. That's romantic. I told you I wasn't offering romance. I'm offering work service in exchange for shelter. Nothing more complicated than that.

It's always more complicated than that. Only if we let it be. He studied her face like he was reading a map, looking for landmarks, trying to figure out where he was. Your children, he said finally. The boy, Jacob.

Yes. He looks at you like you're holding the world together with your bare hands. I am. And the girl, Lily, she's six. She doesn't understand most of what's happening, just that we keep moving and nothing is ever permanent.

That's hard on a child. It's hard on everyone. But children are resilient. They adapt. Sarah's voice softened.

All they really need is to feel safe, feel wanted, know that someone will protect them no matter what. I can give them the first two, but I can't protect them from a Montana winter with 17 cents and no shelter. 17 cents. That's what I have left. Not enough for another stage ticket.

Not enough for a week at the boarding house. Just enough to make sure I can't run anymore, even if I wanted to. Something shifted in his expression. Recognition, maybe. The understanding of someone who'd been trapped by circumstances beyond their control.

The house has three bedrooms, he said slowly. I only use one. The other two have been empty since I built them. Sarah felt her heart begin to pound. Mr.

Monroe. I'm not agreeing to anything yet. He held up a hand. I'm just telling you what exists. Three bedrooms, a kitchen with a stove that heats most of the house, a root cellar full of preserves and vegetables, a smokehouse with enough meat to last until spring.

That sounds like a home. It sounds like a building with food in it. A home requires He stopped. It requires things I don't have. What things? people, noise, complications.

He almost spat the last word. The kind of entanglements that make a man vulnerable, that give the world leverage against him. You think having people in your house makes you weak? I think it gives others power over me that I don't want to give. Sarah took another step toward him, close enough now to see the lines around his eyes, the gray at his temples, the tension in his jaw.

Mr. Monroe Caleb. She used his first name deliberately. I've had power over men before. Not by choice, but because that's how the world works when you're a woman alone.

I've had to smile when I wanted to scream. Say yes when I meant no. Pretend things were fine when they were falling apart. And And I'm tired of it. All I want now is an honest arrangement with an honest man.

You give me shelter. I give you service. We keep our hands to ourselves and our expectations clear. No power games, no manipulation. Just two people helping each other survive.

You make it sound simple. Because it is simple. We're the ones who complicate things with fear and distrust and memories of people who hurt us. Sarah softened her voice. I'm not Margaret.

I'm not going to disappear. I have nowhere to disappear to. That's not exactly reassuring. It's honest. I'd rather give you honest than reassuring.

The snow was falling heavier now, accumulating on their shoulders, turning the world white and quiet. One month, Caleb said. Sarah's breath caught. One month trial. You work.

I provide room and board. At the end of the month, we decide together whether to continue through winter. He paused. If it's not working, I'll pay your stage fair to wherever you want to go. That's generous.

That's practical. If you leave, I don't want you stranded in Silver Creek causing talk and trouble. And if it is working, then we negotiate terms for the winter. Spring comes, we reassess again. His eyes held hers.

No promises, Mrs. Jenkins. No expectations beyond what we explicitly agree to. And no, he stopped. No what?

News in the same category

News Post