Ivy exhaled.
“Thank you.”
Nadia shifted her weight.
“I should have told him to stop before he threw it. I saw him getting ready, and I thought he was just going to make a stupid joke.”
“You couldn't have known he'd throw a punch.”
“No. But I could've said something when he started calling you names last week.”
Ivy did not tell Nadia that her guilt was unnecessary. She understood too well how much courage it took to admit that standing by had been a choice.
Instead she said, “You're speaking now.”
Nadia nodded.
That evening Ivy's parents were waiting for her at the kitchen table.
Mr. Walsh had telephoned them before she arrived, but his summary had not prepared Dana for the sauce still clinging to the ends of her daughter's hair or the exhaustion on her face.
Marcus brought her a glass of water. Lucy sat on the stairs, listening with a worried frown.
Ivy described the cafeteria as carefully as she could.
She told them about the meatball, the taunts, the way Gavin turned to walk away, and the sentence she'd thrown after him.
Dana's expression changed.
“You called him fat?”
“I was angry.”
“I know.”
“He's been calling me poor for months. Everybody laughs. I wanted him to feel it for once.”
Dana waited until Ivy finished.
“You had every right to tell him to stop,” she said. “You had every right to move away when he raised his fist. But using his body as an insult wasn't the only way to stand up for yourself.”
Ivy stared at the table.
“It worked. He finally stopped laughing.”
“For a second,” her mother said. “Then he nearly hit you.”
Marcus leaned forward.
“Your mother's not saying the things were equal. They weren't. Throwing food and taking a swing at somebody are serious choices. What you said was wrong too, but it didn't make him do those things.”
Ivy's eyes filled.
“I knew he'd be angry. I didn't think he'd actually try to punch me.”
Dana came around the table and put an arm around her.
“I'm glad you moved. I'm glad you're here. And I'm glad you can think about your own choices without carrying responsibility for his.”
They sat together until Lucy finally came downstairs.
“Can I ask something?” she said.
Ivy nodded.
“Why didn't anybody help you when he threw the meatball?”
No one answered immediately.
That question remained with Ivy long after she had showered, changed clothes, and put her stained blouse in cold water to soak.
The next morning, Hawthorne's dean called her into a meeting with the student support coordinator and an independent investigator hired by the school.
Her parents attended. Gavin and his family were interviewed separately.
The investigator asked Ivy to describe the sequence without interruption. She did so, including her own remark about his weight, her smile, his punch, and the direction she moved to avoid it.
“Were you smiling because you expected him to hit you?” the investigator asked.
“No,” Ivy answered. “I smiled because for once he didn't get to walk away laughing while everyone looked at me. It felt like I'd finally stood up. Then he raised his fist.”
“Did you intend to strike him?”
“No.”
“Did you strike him?”
“No.”
The investigator made a note. She asked what other incidents had occurred before that day, and Ivy described the water on her library book, the nicknames, the photographs of her sneakers, and the repeated remarks about how her family paid for things.