Karen Called CPS Over My Kids Playing in Dirt — So I Sued Her for Defamation and Won Big!

Chapter 4

Reader Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Here are the permits," I said, handing him a clipboard before he could finish. "Building permit, excavation permit, HOA approval letter for a hardscape modification. And here is the town ordinance highlighting the 7:00 a.m. start time." 

Davis looked at the papers. He looked at the excavator. He looked at Tony, who gave him a polite nod while cleaning his fingernails with a screwdriver. 

"Everything looks in order," Davis said. He looked over at Brenda's house. She was watching from the window. "Look, Mike, I know what's going on here. She's a pain. We know she's a pain, but try to keep the peace." 

"I'm just improving my property, officer. Can't help it if construction is loud." 

Davis nodded and walked over to Brenda's door. I watched on the camera monitor I had set up in the garage. Brenda opened the door. 

"Well, are you going to arrest them?" 

"Ma'am, they have permits. They are allowed to be here. Please stop calling 911 for non-emergencies. It's a violation of the penal code." 

"He's doing this to mock me!" Brenda hissed. "Just like he let his kids play in that filth to mock me. I know what he's doing." 

Davis paused. "Ma'am, on Saturday you said the kids were eating feces. Today you're saying he let them play in dirt to mock you. Which is it?" 

Brenda stiffened. "I... I... I was concerned. It looked like filth." 

"Just stop calling, ma'am, unless there is a crime." Davis left. Brenda slammed the door. 

I reviewed the footage. It was good, but not a smoking gun. She had backpedaled. I needed her to be explicit. I needed her to admit the Saturday call was a lie. 

The next three days were a symphony of malicious compliance. Tony and his crew worked slowly, painfully slowly. They moved dirt from one side of the yard to the other, then moved it back. They left the heavy equipment idling for hours, and every time Brenda came out, I was there smiling, waving. But the real bait was the brown Play-Doh. 

On Thursday afternoon, I set the stage. I bought twenty cans of brown Play-Doh. I sat Leo and Sophie down on the patio table, which was in clear view of Brenda's kitchen window, but just out of earshot for her, but perfect range for my mics. 

"Okay, guys," I said, "we are going to make sculptures. I want you to make the weirdest shapes you can, and we are going to laugh a lot. Okay?" 

"Okay!" Sophie cheered. 

We started molding the brown dough. From a distance, specifically the distance of Brenda's window, it looked suspicious. It looked exactly like what she had accused them of eating on Saturday. I saw the curtains move. The binoculars came out. 

I grabbed a chunk of the brown dough. "Hey, Leo, watch this." I held it up, pretended to take a huge bite, and swallowed it. I palmed it, obviously, but from her angle, it looked like I just ate a turd. 

Leo laughed hysterically. He grabbed a piece and pretended to eat it, too. 

I checked the audio feed on my phone. Brenda was on the phone immediately, but not to the police. She was calling her friend, Linda. The mic picked it up crystal clear. 

*"Linda, you won't believe it. He's doing it again. They are sitting on the patio eating something brown. No, I don't think it's actual poop this time. It looks like clay or something, but it looks disgusting."* 

Pause. Linda must have said something. Brenda laughed. A cruel, cackling sound. 

*"I know. I know. It's probably just food or dough, but it looks terrible. I'm going to call CPS again. If I keep calling, they'll have to take the kids away. Or at least he'll get so scared he'll list the house. I just want him gone. Linda, I don't care if the kids are actually safe or not. I just want that trashy truck out of my view. I told the cops they were eating poop last time and they bought it hook, line, and sinker. If I say he's feeding them... I don't know, drugs? Do you think that's too much? No, I'll say they are eating animal waste again. It worked the first time to get the raid."* 

My heart stopped. Then it started beating like a war drum. And there it was. The confession. 

*I don't care if the kids are actually safe. I told the cops they were eating poop and they bought it. It worked the first time to get the raid.* 

She admitted knowledge of falsity. She admitted malicious intent. She admitted she was weaponizing the state against my children to improve her view. I hit save on the recording. I backed it up to the cloud. I backed it up to a USB drive. I emailed it to myself. 

Then I waited for the sirens. 

They came twenty minutes later, but this time I wasn't scared. I was ready. When Caseworker Jenkins got out of the car, she looked furious. She marched up the driveway, Officer Davis trailing behind her, shaking his head. 

"Mr. Miller," she barked. "We received another report." 

"Let me guess," I said, not moving from my chair on the patio, still holding a lump of Play-Doh. "Brenda said we were eating poop again." 

"The report stated you were force-feeding the children animal waste," Jenkins said, disgust radiating off her. 

I held up the can. "Play-Doh, Miss Jenkins. Non-toxic, brown. Would you like to try some? It's salty." 

Jenkins stopped. She looked at the can. She looked at the kids who were giggling. She looked at the spotless patio. "Is this a joke to you?" she asked. 

"No," I said, standing up. "It's not a joke. It's harassment. And I have proof." I pulled out my phone. "Officer Davis, Miss Jenkins, before you inspect my house again, I would like you to listen to something. I have a security system that records audio on my property. My neighbor speaks very loudly." 

I pressed play. Brenda's voice, tinny but unmistakable, drifted from the speaker: *"I know it's probably just food... I don't care if the kids are actually safe. I told the cops they were eating poop last time and they bought it. It worked the first time..."* 

Officer Davis's face went from tired to stone-cold rigid. Jenkins's mouth fell open. The recording ended. 

"She lied," Jenkins whispered. "She knowingly filed a false report of child abuse." 

"Twice," I said. "And she admitted that the first one, the one that put my name in your system, was a fabrication to get you to raid my house." 

Jenkins looked at Officer Davis. "That is a crime, officer. A serious one." 

News in the same category

News Post

Karen Called CPS Over My Kids Playing in Dirt — So I Sued Her for Defamation and Won Big!

6 Part