But curiosity got the better of her, and she slipped down the servants’ stair to watch from the gallery above the entrance hall, hidden behind the balustrade, the way she used to watch her mother greet guests before everything changed.
The Duke of Blackthorn arrived exactly on time, which seemed to unsettle her father more than if he’d been late. He was tall, dark-coated, and utterly still in a way that made the rest of the room look frantic by comparison. He did not smile at Marguerite’s curtsy. He did not linger on Isolde’s carefully arranged beauty. His eyes swept the hall once, briskly, like a man checking a room for something misplaced.
Lord Devereux stepped forward, all practiced warmth. “Your Grace, welcome to Ashford Manor. May I present my daughters?”
“Where is Lady Serafina Devereux?”
The words landed like a dropped glass.
For a moment, no one moved. Marguerite’s smile froze mid-curve. Isolde’s fan stopped fluttering. Lady Cordelia’s face went the color of old paper.
“Your Grace,” her father said carefully, “I believe there’s been some confusion. My daughters are—”
“I asked for Lady Serafina.”
The duke’s voice didn’t rise. It didn’t need to.
“Not her sisters. Her.”
Above them, hidden in the shadows of the gallery, Serafina went very still. She had never heard her name spoken like that in this house, not as an accusation, not as a whisper of shame, but plainly, as though it were simply a fact that mattered.
“She is indisposed,” Lady Cordelia managed. “Unwell. Not fit to receive guests of your standing.”
“Then I will wait until she is fit.”
“Your Grace, surely my other daughters—”
“I did not travel three days to meet your other daughters.”
The silence that followed was the loudest thing Serafina had ever heard. Her father’s jaw tightened.
“Forgive me, Your Grace, but you have never set foot in this house. How do you know my daughter Serafina at all?”
The duke turned, and for the first time his gaze lifted, not toward the family gathered before him, but toward the gallery above, toward the shadows where a girl in a plain gray dress stood frozen behind the railing.
Serafina’s breath caught. He couldn’t possibly see her, and yet for one unbearable second it felt as though he did.
“That,” the duke said quietly, turning back to her stunned father, “is not a question I intend to answer tonight.”
He removed his gloves unhurriedly and handed them to a waiting servant. “I understand dinner is being prepared. I won’t be sitting for it, not until Lady Serafina joins the table herself.”
Lady Cordelia’s mouth opened and closed without sound. The Duke of Blackthorn simply stood there, patient as stone, waiting for a girl the family had spent years trying to erase.
Serafina came down because refusing was no longer an option. Not with the Duke of Blackthorn standing in the entrance hall, refusing dinner on her account in front of every servant and neighbor who would talk about it for weeks.
She wore the same plain gray dress. She hadn’t been given time or permission to change. When she entered the dining room, conversation stopped. Marguerite’s eyes narrowed. Isolde looked faintly ill. Her father wouldn’t meet her gaze at all.
The duke rose from his seat. No one had ever risen for her before.
“Lady Serafina,” he said, and pulled out the chair directly beside his own, not down the table where the family had clearly intended to seat her, if they’d intended to seat her at all. “Thank you for joining us.”